Without automated identity governance tools, approving access requests is a cross‑department effort managed through emails, spreadsheets, and ticketing systems. A manual workflow can still work well as long as it’s clearly defined, consistently followed, and documented.
Let's go through how to build a reliable manual approval workflow for access requests in any organization.
1. Define the Types of Access That Require Approval
Start by identifying what people can request and what categories those requests fall into.
Common access types include:
- Software access (CRM, accounting, project management tools)
- File share or department‑specific folder permissions
- Elevated roles (admin, power user, reporting access)
- Temporary access for short‑term projects
- Hardware requests tied to permissions (laptops, mobile devices)
Make sure this information is clear up front so that there is no unnecessary back-and-forth and everyone understands what counts as a formal request.
2. Establish Who Approves What
You need a clear matrix showing who signs off on which requests.
Approval responsibilities often fall to:
- The employee’s direct manager
- The receiving department’s manager
- IT for system‑specific validations
- HR for sensitive or compliance‑related systems
- Security for access to restricted environments
Keep this approval matrix in a shared, easy‑to‑find location.
3. Determine the Request Intake Method
Access requests typically arrive in an email or an internal form notifying IT.
A simple request should include:
- Employee name
- Department and manager
- System or resource requested
- Reason for access
- Whether it’s permanent or temporary
Encourage managers to submit requests rather than end users to reduce unauthorized or unclear requests.
4. Track Requests in a Centralized Spreadsheet
Manual workflows involve several stakeholders, so a shared spreadsheet is essential.
Your tracker should include:
- Request date
- Requester
- Access needed
- Approval status (Pending / Approved / Denied)
- Date completed
- Notes or follow‑ups
Color‑coding and filters make the spreadsheet easy to use during reviews.
5. Route Requests for Approval Through Email
Once a request is logged, it needs to be approved.
Email typically serves as the approval channel:
- IT emails the appropriate approver(s) with the request details
- Managers reply with approval or additional questions
- IT logs the approval in the spreadsheet
- Approval emails are attached or linked to the ticket (if applicable)
Keep the conversation in a single email thread to preserve the audit trail and avoid confusion.
6. Create a Ticket for Each Approved Request
Once approvals are confirmed, IT should create a ticket to implement the change.
Each ticket should contain:
- The approved access details
- The approval timestamp and the name of the approver
- Any instructions or constraints (temporary access, limited privileges)
- Links to relevant documentation or existing permissions
7. Implement the Access Changes
Common steps include:
- Adding the user to the correct group or role
- Assigning licenses
- Granting folder or file‑share permissions
- Configuring app‑specific roles
- Setting expiration dates for temporary access (record manually if needed)
A quick test login or a screenshot from the admin console can confirm the change before closing the ticket.
8. Verify Changes With the Requesting Manager
Before marking the ticket as complete, confirm that the access is correct and sufficient.
Verification steps:
- Manager confirms the employee can perform the tasks requiring access
- Employee confirms functionality
- IT updates the spreadsheet and marks the ticket resolved
9. Maintain an Approval Archive
Manual processes need strong documentation for audits, compliance reviews, and investigations.
Keep copies of:
- Approval emails
- Completed tickets
- Monthly or quarterly review summaries
10. Review Access Regularly
Least‑privilege access only works when it’s regularly enforced, so scheduled reviews are essential.
Review cycles might include:
- Quarterly checks for sensitive systems
- Semi‑annual reviews for department‑wide access
- Annual audits for full access rights across the organization
When you review access regularly, you can catch outdated access from past roles, one‑off projects, or temporary approvals that were never revoked.
Note About Manual Approval Workflows
Manual workflows can absolutely work, especially for an organization without complex access needs or sophisticated tools. However, you will have to rely heavily on good communication, disciplined tracking, and consistent oversight. As your number of systems and users grows, manual steps become harder to maintain, making structured processes like these even more important.
Do you want to streamline your onboarding and offboarding process? Provision Flow will automate provisioning, hardware ordering, license purchase, welcome emails, and task assignments in a seamless flow. Learn more at httpsss://provisionflow.com/
__ __

